Use-value, exchange-value and money

The Introduction to Marxism site, written and designed by Dino Felluga and hosted by Purdue University, is an invaluable resource. The module “On Fetishism” explains Marx’s distinction between the use-value and the exchange value of the commodity. Use-value is inextricably tied to “the physical properties of the commodity“; that is, the material uses to which the object can actually be put, the human needs it fulfills. In the exchange of goods on the capitalist market, however, exchange-value dominates: two commodities can be exchanged on the open market because they are always being compared to a third term that functions as their “universal equivalent,” a function that is eventually taken over by money (Felluga, Dino. “Modules on Marx: On Fetishism.” Introductory Guide to Critical Theory).

But what is money?  Following Marx, David Hawkes conceptualizes money as a symbol of human labor power.  In this podcast, Hawkes discusses Marx’s central concepts, but applies them to pre-industrial and post-colonial contexts (it runs approx. one hour).

“Money, Finance, and the Power of Symbols,” Against the Grain,” KPFA, 3.07.12.

At the heart of the global economy, a regime dominated by lending and finance, is a symbol we call money. What does this say about who we are and how we work, and what ethical judgments can and should be made about money, wage labor, and capital investment? David Hawkes draws connections among money, human labor-time, usury, and other cultures’ beliefs in magic.

Hawkes emphasizes how usury (understood as lending for interest, in general) historically has been seen as a violation of both spiritual and natural laws.  All previous systems of philosophy or world religions, all systems of thought, condemn usury, yet “usury runs our economy,” Hawkes asserts.  Hawkes links usury to the distinction between use-value and exchange-value, which he traces back to Aristotle.  Aristotle’s main objection to usury was that it’s “unnatural” in that it takes something that is not part of nature and allows it to “reproduce,” and to acquire needs, desires, impulses and interests.  In the view of Aristotle and Marx, the purpose of economic activity is to produce use-value, things we can use — not money. Both Aristotle and Marx warned of the dangers of the rule of money (including the fetishization of money).


3 responses to “Use-value, exchange-value and money

  1. I must agree with Aristotle’s view on money because it is “unnatural”. Money cannot be found in nature obviously , but however somehow this peice of paper can help humans obain anything they want with a snap of a finger. I have to agree with Marx also because if everyone produced something and helped eachother their would not be any difference between me and you. But money draws the line in different classes of society. Money is what seperates and differentiates human beings in many different ways such as what cars we drive and what neighborhoods we live in. However I must say that money is the root of evil in my eyes. Imagine a world without money. Would their be as many problems in this beautiful world of ours if money had never existed?

  2. sad but true the “fetishization of money” which Marx detests and which Aristotle terms as “unnatural,” has actually become the norm wherein everything revolves. And those that regard money less than the simple things in life are seen as absurd. And we all know that somehow, we need to keep up.

  3. In today’s society the fetishization of money that Aristotle and Marx warned us about is seen as normal. Money and how much of it you acquire is what separates different people into classes and different socioeconomic statuses. If we just produced the amount of goods we needed as individuals and exchanged for the good of others then “fetishization” of money would not be seen so negatively. However, the main motive behind everything in today’s society is how much money can one obtain.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s